Dental Marketing Resources

Here’s Why It’s Getting Harder and Harder to Measure Google Rankings

Written by Alexa Smith | Nov 18, 2026, 8:45:58 PM

If you've opened your keyword report lately and noticed more blank spots, more "not ranking" labels, or keywords that jump from page one to nowhere and back again, you're not imagining it. You're also not alone. Practices all over the country are seeing the same thing.

Here's the good news: in most cases, your practice didn't lose its spot on Google. What changed is how ranking tools can see Google. Below, we'll explain what's going on in plain English, what it means for your practice, and what our SEO team watches instead.

What's Happening

Ranking tools work by sending automated searches to Google, thousands every day, and writing down where your website shows up. Think of it as a robot that types "dentist near me" into Google over and over and records the results.

This year, Google made that robot's job much harder. Since late summer 2026:

  • Google changed the links in its search results. Every result now goes through an extra Google link first, so tools have to do far more work to read each result. Google confirmed this change and described it as part of protecting search from abuse.
  • Google started blocking many automated searches. In mid-September, several tools reported large drops in how much data they could collect.
  • Some tools started getting results that don't match what real patients see. Sometimes the results showed businesses from a different city, or websites that had nothing to do with the search.

Google hasn't publicly explained the last two changes. But the pattern is clear: Google is cracking down on automated searches, and ranking tools are caught in the middle.

This Is Happening to Every Ranking Tool, Not Just Ours

This isn't one tool having a bad month. Every major ranking tool has reported problems:

  • STAT, the tool we use, posted public updates in August, September, and October. They fixed the link change, then flagged that Google was serving results from places that didn't match the search, which can cause "sudden ranking shifts" in reports.
  • Semrush said the impact on its data was limited and mostly beyond page one (Search Engine Roundtable).
  • Ahrefs estimated that 5% to 20% of results were affected, depending on the data source (PPC Land).
  • SE Ranking studied 10,000 keywords and found that bad results almost always appeared below position 9 and never in the top 5 (SE Ranking).
  • AccuRanker, Nozzle, and Sistrix reported similar problems and have been adjusting how they collect data.

So when you see a blank or a sudden drop, it usually means the tool couldn't get a clean reading that day. It doesn't mean patients can't find you.

Think of It Like a Broken Thermometer

If a thermometer reads 98.6 one day and 106 the next, but your patient looks and feels completely fine, you'd check the thermometer before you'd call an ambulance.

Keyword rankings are a reading. New patient calls are the vital sign. Right now, the thermometer is glitchy, but the vital signs are what tell us how your practice is really doing.

The Glitches Mostly Hit Page 2 and Beyond

This is the most reassuring part. Across the tools that have shared data, the bad readings show up mostly on page 2 of Google and deeper. Patients rarely scroll that far.

And most bad readings don't stick around. One tool found that nearly 8 in 10 strange results looked normal again when rechecked within a few days (Nozzle). That's why a keyword can be "not ranking" on Tuesday and back on page one on Thursday.

Why Your Impressions Might Be Down Too

Your report may also show a drop in impressions. An impression is counted each time your website appears in someone's Google results, whether or not they click. Google reports this number in a free tool called Google Search Console.

Across the 220+ practices we work with, impressions dropped about 20% from August to September 2026. But clicks only dropped about 8%, and October held steady. In other words, Google counted fewer "views," but real people kept clicking through to practice websites at nearly the same rate.

The most likely reason: some of those old impressions were never patients at all. They were ranking tools loading Google results. When Google blocked the tools, those robot "views" disappeared from the count. Google hasn't confirmed this, but it's the leading explanation in the SEO industry, and it matches what we see in our own data. Going forward, we treat September as the new starting point for comparing impressions.

Not Every Change Is a Glitch

We'd be doing you a disservice if we blamed everything on the tools. Google also updated how it ranks websites during this same stretch:

  • A spam update ran from September 24 to October 8, 2026.
  • A core update, one of Google's bigger ranking changes, rolled out over roughly two weeks starting November 10, 2026 (Search Engine Roundtable).

Updates like these can move real rankings, up or down. That's exactly why our SEO team doesn't take any single number at face value.

How Our SEO Team Reads Your Rankings Now

When the tools are this unreliable, the people reading them matter more than ever. Here are the rules our SEO team follows:

  1. We never react to a one-day drop. We recheck it and look at the trend over several weeks.
  2. We check Google's own data first. Before calling anything a real drop, we confirm it in Google Search Console, which shows what actually happened with real searchers.
  3. We look for signs of a bad reading. Unfamiliar websites, businesses from other cities, or results unrelated to the search are red flags that the tool captured a bad snapshot.
  4. We match changes against Google updates. If a real shift lines up with an update, we study it before changing anything on your site.
  5. We report bad readings to our tool provider. That helps their fixes get better, faster.
  6. We judge success by calls and new patients. Rankings help us diagnose. Leads tell us whether your marketing is working.

What to Look At in Your Report Instead

If you only have a minute with your monthly report, here's where to look, in order:

  1. Your Leads Page. Phone calls, form submissions, and appointment requests from your website. This is the closest thing to new patients walking in the door.
  2. Clicks from Google. These are real people choosing your website. Clicks have stayed much steadier than rankings or impressions through all of this.
  3. Rankings, as a general direction. Rankings are still useful for spotting trends over months. Just don't read too much into any single keyword on any single day.

The Bottom Line

Google is changing fast, and the tools that measure it are working to keep up. Blank spots and jumpy rankings in your report are mostly a measurement problem, not a sign that patients can't find you.

Our job is to cut through the noise and focus on what grows your practice: more calls, more appointment requests, and more new patients. If you have questions about anything in your report, reach out to your Marketing Coach. We're always happy to walk through it with you.